Audit

Audit confirmations in Saudi Arabia: why the auditor writes to your bank

Imad Khan · Founder · 12+ years

Under ISA 505, as SOCPA endorsed it, an external confirmation is a direct written reply to the auditor from a bank, customer, supplier or other third party. The auditor chooses what to ask, who to ask, and keeps the reply. The company authorises the request and gives a correct contact. A missing reply is followed by alternative procedures, and a refusal by management can affect the opinion.

9 min read
ShareWhatsAppLinkedIn
Article cover: Audit confirmations in Saudi Arabia: why the auditor writes to your bank

Who may receive a letter

ISA 330, paragraph 19, says the auditor considers whether external confirmation procedures are to be performed as substantive procedures. Paragraph A50 lists situations where they may provide relevant evidence. The list is examples, not a rule that every item is confirmed on every audit.

PartyWhat is usually confirmedSource
BankBalances and other information relevant to the banking relationshipISA 330, A50
CustomersAccounts receivable balances and termsISA 330, A50
SuppliersAccounts payable balances and termsISA 330, A50
LendersAmounts due, including repayment terms and restrictive covenantsISA 330, A50
A warehouse or processorInventories held by third parties for processing or on consignmentISA 330, A50
A lawyer or financierProperty title deeds held for safe custody or as securityISA 330, A50
A custodian or brokerInvestments held for safekeeping, or purchased but not delivered at the balance-sheet dateISA 330, A50

Paragraph A50 also says the auditor may confirm the terms of agreements, or the absence of a side agreement. Paragraph A51 says a confirmation is stronger evidence of whether a receivable exists than of whether it will be collected.

Why the auditor writes

ISA 505 defines an external confirmation as audit evidence obtained as a direct written response to the auditor from a third party, on paper, electronically, or by another medium. A positive request asks the party to reply in every case, agreeing or disagreeing, or filling in the information. A negative request asks for a reply only if the party disagrees. Paragraph 15 says a negative confirmation is less persuasive, and it is not used as the only substantive procedure for an assessed risk unless every condition in that paragraph is met.

Paragraph 7 says the auditor maintains control. The auditor determines the information, selects the confirming party, designs the request so the reply comes directly to the auditor, and sends the request, including any follow-up. Paragraph A4 says a confirming party may be willing to reply only if the request contains management's authorisation. Paragraph A6 says checking the address includes testing the validity of some or all of the addresses before the requests go out. Paragraph A7 says a follow-up, after the original address is checked again, is something the auditor may send when a reply has not arrived in a reasonable time. The standard does not set that time, and this page does not invent one.

SOCPA's published reply on sending the letters says the auditor may send them through management if the auditor still maintains the control in paragraph 7. The reply itself still has to reach the auditor directly. The same reply, and paragraph A15, say an oral response on its own is not an external confirmation. A separate published reply says a SIMAH credit report is not an external confirmation, because it is not a direct written response to the auditor from the confirming party.

The paper file around the letters is in audit documents required in Saudi Arabia. Inventory held by the company, rather than by a third party, is in the stock-count guide. A confirmation of a loan covenant is not the going-concern conclusion. That question is in going concern in a Saudi audit.

What the company does

Give the auditor the right legal name, account numbers and a current contact, and sign the authorisation the confirming party may require. Reconcile the bank, customer and supplier balances to the draft statements before the request is designed, so a difference is not a surprise in the reply. Do not collect the reply and hand it over later. Paragraph 7(c) requires the request to contain return information so the response is sent directly to the auditor. If the auditor asks the company to send a letter, that is still under the auditor's control, on the wording of SOCPA's published reply. It is not a handover of the procedure.

Chasing a silent party is a follow-up under paragraph 7(d) and A7. The auditor sends it, or directs it. The company does not run a parallel chase that produces a reply the auditor did not receive.

If nobody replies

A non-response, in paragraph 6, is a failure to respond or to respond fully to a positive request, or a request returned undelivered. Paragraph 12 says that for each non-response the auditor performs alternative audit procedures to obtain relevant and reliable evidence. Paragraph A18 gives examples. For receivables, those examples are specific subsequent cash receipts, shipping documentation, and sales near the period end. For payables, they are subsequent cash disbursements, correspondence from third parties, and other records such as goods-received notes. Paragraph A19 says the procedures depend on the account and the assertion, and that fewer replies than expected may be a fraud risk factor the auditor evaluates under ISA 240.

Paragraph 13 is the limit on those alternatives. If the auditor has determined that a response to a positive request is necessary to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence, alternative procedures will not provide the evidence required. If that confirmation is not obtained, the auditor determines the implications for the audit and the opinion under ISA 705 (Revised). Paragraph A20 gives two illustrations: the information that would corroborate management's assertion exists only outside the entity, and fraud risk factors, such as management override or collusion, stop the auditor relying on evidence from inside the entity. What a qualified, adverse or disclaimer opinion is, is in audit opinion types. This page does not choose which of those follows a particular silence.

If you do not want a party contacted

Paragraph 8 applies when management refuses to allow the auditor to send a request. The auditor asks why, and seeks evidence that the reason is valid and reasonable. The auditor evaluates what the refusal does to the risk of material misstatement, including fraud, and to the other procedures, and performs alternative procedures designed to obtain relevant and reliable evidence. Paragraph A8 says a common reason is a legal dispute or an ongoing negotiation with the intended party, where an untimely request might affect the resolution. The auditor still seeks evidence for that reason, because of the risk that management is denying access to evidence that may reveal fraud or error.

Paragraph 9 is the next step. If the auditor concludes the refusal is unreasonable, or cannot obtain relevant and reliable evidence from the alternatives, the auditor communicates with those charged with governance under ISA 260 (Revised), and determines the implications for the audit and the opinion under ISA 705 (Revised). Tell the auditor the reason before the request is stopped. Do not assume a dispute, on its own, ends the procedure.

When the reply does not match the books

An exception, in paragraph 6, is a response that shows a difference between the information requested, or the information in the entity's records, and the information the confirming party provides. Paragraph 14 says the auditor investigates exceptions to determine whether they indicate misstatements. Paragraph A21 says an identified misstatement is evaluated under ISA 240 for whether it indicates fraud, and that exceptions may also indicate a deficiency in internal control. Paragraph A22 says some exceptions are not misstatements. The examples are timing, measurement, or clerical errors in the confirmation procedures. A customer who paid after the year-end, or a supplier invoice recorded in the next period, can be that kind of difference. The auditor investigates it. The company does not decide that it does not count.

The written representations about the statements and the information given to the auditor are a separate letter. That letter is in the representation-letter guide. A confirmation reply is evidence from outside the company. The representation letter is evidence from management. One does not replace the other.

Before the requests go out

  • Reconcile bank, customer and supplier balances to the draft statements, including facilities and loan terms where a lender will be asked about covenants.
  • Prepare the authorisation the confirming party may require, and a contact whose address the auditor can test.
  • Tell the auditor now if a party is in a dispute or a negotiation, and put the evidence of that reason with the explanation.
  • Leave the sending, the follow-up and the receipt with the auditor.
  • If a reply shows a difference, have the subsequent receipt, the shipping document or the goods-received note ready. Those are the examples in paragraph A18. They do not decide the opinion.

The deposit of the statements and the Zakat return sit on different clocks. The year-end calendar keeps the six-month Qawaem deposit, under Companies Law Article 17, apart from the 120-day Zakat return. Neither date chooses who is confirmed.

Get help

If confirmation requests are about to go out and a balance, a contact or a refusal is not agreed, get matched. See financial audit in Saudi Arabia, Zakat consultancy, and the pages for Riyadh, Jeddah and Dammam. Or message the Saudi line on WhatsApp at +966 53 830 0029. ISZ Global matches you with a licensed auditor. It does not send the confirmation, receive the reply, sign the opinion, or deposit the statements.

Who deposits, and what a missed deposit can lead to, stays in who uploads on Qawaem, the Qawaem warning guide and the catch-up guide. One published case study, name withheld, does not describe a confirmation.

Official sources

Last reviewed 17 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What is an external confirmation?

ISA 505, endorsed by SOCPA as issued by the IAASB, defines it as audit evidence obtained as a direct written response to the auditor from a third party, on paper or by electronic or other medium. An oral reply on its own is not that confirmation.

Who sends the letter, and who receives the reply?

Paragraph 7 says the auditor maintains control, including sending the request and any follow-up, and designing it so the reply comes directly to the auditor. SOCPA's published reply says the auditor may send through management if that control is kept. The reply still has to reach the auditor.

What if the bank or the customer does not reply?

Paragraph 12 says the auditor performs alternative procedures for each non-response. Paragraph A18 gives examples such as subsequent cash receipts and shipping documents for receivables, and subsequent payments and goods-received notes for payables. Paragraph 13 says that if a positive reply was necessary, those alternatives do not replace it, and the auditor considers the opinion under ISA 705.

Can management stop a confirmation?

Paragraph 8 says the auditor asks for the reason and seeks evidence that it is valid and reasonable, then evaluates the risk, including fraud, and performs alternative procedures. A legal dispute or a negotiation is a common reason in paragraph A8, and it still has to be evidenced. If the refusal is unreasonable, or the alternatives fail, paragraph 9 requires communication with those charged with governance and a consideration of the opinion.

Does a difference in the reply mean the books are wrong?

Not always. Paragraph 14 requires the auditor to investigate the exception. Paragraph A22 says some differences are timing, measurement or clerical errors in the confirmation itself, and are not misstatements. The auditor makes that determination.

Does ISZ Global send the confirmation or sign the opinion?

No. ISZ Global matches you with a licensed auditor. It does not send the confirmation, receive the reply, sign the opinion, or deposit the statements.

Related guides

Article cover: Losses at half of capital in Saudi Arabia: the 60-day rule

Losses at half of capital in Saudi Arabia: the 60-day rule

If a limited liability company's losses amount to half its capital, Companies Law Article 182 says the manager calls the partners' general assembly within 60 days from the date he knows. The meeting considers continuing, by taking measures necessary to resolve the losses, or dissolving. A joint-stock company has a different pair of deadlines under Article 132. The Law does not define how the loss figure is measured against capital.

Audit8 min read

Article cover: End-of-service benefits in a Saudi audit: the liability before anyone leaves

End-of-service benefits in a Saudi audit: the liability before anyone leaves

The Labor Law award is half a month's wage for each of the first five years and a month's wage for each year after that, on the last wage, with part-years in proportion. Section 28 of the IFRS for SMEs Standard requires the cost of benefits employees have already earned to be recognised as a liability, not only when someone leaves. The auditor tests that amount as an accounting estimate under ISA 540 (Revised), as SOCPA endorsed it.

Audit9 min read

Article cover: Related party transactions in a Saudi audit: owner loans and the other company

Related party transactions in a Saudi audit: owner loans and the other company

Under ISA 550, as SOCPA endorsed it, the auditor asks who the related parties are, what was done with them, and whether the statements reflect that under the reporting framework. For most Saudi private companies that framework is the IFRS for SMEs Standard, and Section 33 is the disclosure section. An owner loan, a sale to the owner's other company, and a cost the owner paid for the company are the usual places that section is tested.

Audit9 min read

Related case studies

Get matched+971 58 140 7965